Which edition is right for me?

Which Edition is Best for Me?

best sheet music editions

 

There are various good editions for the music you are working on. WIth so many options, you must ask yourself, which edition should I purchase?

While this website offers its opinions on what the best editions are, what this website recommends the most may not actually be the best edition that you are looking for.

For example, the Barenreiter Urtext, a leading edition for composers such as Bach, Beethoven, and Mozart, does not include fingering suggestions. This is very suitable for the polyphonic music of Bach, in which there are multiple ways to find a suitable fingering for yourself. However, with a work such as a Beethoven Concerto, it may be extremely helpful to have fingering suggestions.

With Chopin, the current leading edition is the Polish National Edition. However, you may find that the Durand Edition edited by Alfred Cortot to be a more suitable edition for Chopin. The reason being is that Cortot wrote many exercises and practices to go with the Chopin works. These exercises give certain insights on how to properly perform a difficult passage.

Here you can purchase the leading National Edition for Chopin Etudes:

best sheet music editions

Etudes: Chopin National Edition 2A, Vol. II (Works Published During Chopin’s Lifetime)

Durand Edition edited by Alfred Cortot:

best sheet music editions

12 Studies Op10 Piano Etudes (English Text)

best sheet music editions

12 Studies Op. 25 Piano Etudes (English Text) (Musical Expeditions)

Editions to Not Buy

If you purchase a score of classical music, and the publishing company for that edition is not listed anywhere on this website, chances are, you have spent your money buying a bad edition to your music.

This edition is an example of a score you do not want to buy:

 

IMG_0324

This edition of Beethoven’s Fifth Piano Concerto by Classical Music Collection is quite bad. There is no information inside of this book about the publishing date. Also, there is not an introductory note or comments mentioning about the sources for making this edition. While this edition was very inexpensive, it is better to use IMSLP than to spend money and use an edition such as this.

best sheet music editions piano

As seen from this picture, the print is this edition is extremely tiny! You will have to squint your eyes in order to see the notes on this page. You do not want to have to spend extra time learning a piece of music simply because you cannot see the notes that well. This will only cause frustration and anger.

Safe yourself from such an inconvenience and buy the best edition for your music. If you are going to spend money, then you should do it right!

Buy Best Edition Beethoven

The most recommended edition for Beethoven’s Fifth Piano Concerto on this website is the Barenreiter Urtext.

best sheet music editions

Concerto for Pianoforte and Orchestra No. 5 E-flat Major Op. 73. Full Score. Piano reduction, Part(s), Urtext edition. 1st Printing 2015.

Of course, if you find an edition for this score, such as the Henle Verlag Urtext, Wiener, Edition Peters, or even the Schirmer, you will still have a good edition for your music.

 

The Leading Edition vs IMSLP

Chopin Scherzo 2 examined

 

In this post, we will examine the difference between using the leading edition for Chopin, the National Edition, and the cheap, free edition one can get from IMSLP.

While IMSLP is a good internet domain which provides quality information about classical music, it is dangerous to study a music score seriously from this website.

At best, you should only use music on IMSLP in case of an emergency, such as a last second rehearsal, or while you are waiting for your authentic score to come to you in the mail.

Measures 265 – 276 Examined

In this excerpt, Measures 265 – 276 of the Chopin Scherzo No. 2 are examined.

Here are images of the scores:

National Edition

best sheet music editions
Image used with permission of National Editions

Jan Ekier is the editor for this edition.

IMSLP

best sheet music editions

Herrmann Scholtz is the editor for the IMSLP score.

Already, visually speaking, we can see a stark difference between these two editions.

The National Edition features larger print, which makes it easier to read. The IMSLP version is very small, and it is harder to read some of the details such as the slurs, ties, and phrasing.

In the first and second measures (M. 265-266), we can already see a difference with the details. Notice how the C-sharp is sustained in the IMSLP version, but not in the National Edition? This is problematic.

The correct way to play this passage is to not sustain the C-sharp. In the International Chopin Competition in Warsaw (who are recommended to study their pieces using the Polish National Edition – Source ), performers of this piece do not sustain the C-sharp in this measure.

In Measure 285-286 (not shown) the C-sharp becomes sustained in the National Edition, creating contrast between the two passages.

Also, take a close look at the counter melody in this passage. Do you notice a difference with the rhythms in the two editions? In Measure 268, the IMSLP version has the D as a dotted quarter note, followed by an eighth note with the C. In the National Edition, these notes are quarter notes.

In addition, look at the phrasing in these two editions from measures 265-276. The National Edition shows clear markings between each phrase. There is a slur connecting the phrase from M. 265-268, and M. 269-274. However, in Scholtz’s score from IMSLP, he chooses to use a slur from M 265-276. Using a slur in this way creates a completely different musical phrase.

Measures 334 – 341 Examined

National Edition 

best sheet music editions
Image used with permission by National Editions

IMSLP 

best sheet music editions

 

There are two issues that will be addressed within these excerpts.

These issues are fingering and pedaling.

Having good fingering is of utmost importance, as it will determine the success of playing a passage of music. With bad fingering, you may spend countless hours working on a passage, only to find that you will never play it well. This may lead to belittling oneself, and believing that you are not very skilled at the piano.

In measures 337-338, there is a difficult passage that requires critical thinking in terms of use of fingering. In the IMSLP version, it is recommended to use the fifth finger on the G-sharp in measure 337. Using this finger may work with slow practice, but once you play this passage at tempo, you will have extreme difficulty playing this note with your pinky. This is because your pinky finger is not very strong and is not the most suitable finger to use on a black key.

The Polish National version recommends to use the fourth finger, the ring finger, on this G-sharp. This finger is more suited for this passage, and will ensure a smooth performance of it. It also offers multiple suggested fingerings for the succeeding notes.

In addition, notice the difference in the use of pedaling between these two editions. In the National Edition, the pedal is sustained through measures 334 to the beginning of 336. This enables the bass line to come out more. With the IMSLP version, each measure is pedaled again. This makes it more difficult for the bass line to come out.

Purchase Best Edition Chopin

You can purchase the leading edition to the Chopin Scherzi here:

National Edition

best sheet music editions

Scherzos: Chopin National Edition 9A, Vol. IX (National Edition of the Works of Fryderyk Chopin, Series a: Works Published During Chopin’s Lifetime / Wydanie Narodowe Dziel Fryderyka Chopina, Serie)